The Shield

Where’s the accountability?

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






The Ohio State Board of Trustees failed their university.

They failed their students, they failed their employees, but most importantly they failed Courtney Smith.

The university suspended its head football coach Urban Meyer Aug. 22 for three games after an investigation into his mishandling of domestic violence claims against his former assistant Zach Smith.

The trustees coalesced an independent investigation panel to head a two-week inquiry into what Meyer, who coached OSU to a national championship in 2014, knew about the allegations.

Meyer has amassed a 73-8 record since taking the job at Ohio State in 2012. He has been on paid leave since Aug. 1 and will be suspended for the first three games of the season against Oregon State, Rutgers and Texas Christian University (TCU).

This is not a steep enough penalty for Meyer’s actions.

No, what he did does not even come close to the heinous abuse Zach Smith potentially levied against his wife, but according to the panel’s report, Meyer possibly knew about the abuse and did nothing.

That would be concerning by itself, but the report also suggests that Meyer may have deleted all of his text messages that dated back more than a year ago.

Based on this evidence, he pretty much lied at the Big Ten media day when he said he knew nothing about the allegations.

All of this considered, when Meyer was asked at a press conference the day of his suspension what he had to say to Courtney Smith, the wife of Zach Smith, he said, “I have a message for everyone involved. I’m sorry we’re in this situation.”

You read that right. He didn’t even apologize directly to Courtney Smith.

Throughout the entirety of the press conference, especially that quote, Meyer acted as though he was the victim, as though he was the one who had suffered through immense pain.

Urban Meyer doesn’t care about Courtney Smith. He doesn’t care about Zach Smith or his players, or even Ohio State. All he cares about is himself and his reputation.

Meyer had several opportunities to address the situation and help put a stop to it based on the investigation and multiple media reports. He chose not to do so. He chose to ignore it because of the scrutiny his football program would have received if word got out.

To all the coaches, teachers and leaders out there, heed this statement: Your reputation is never more important than someone’s well-being.

Being suspended for three games that Ohio State will probably win anyway simply isn’t an adequate punishment.

As the head of a college football program and a leader of young men, Meyer has the responsibility of being a role model and combating injustice wherever it arises, especially inside his own program.

There is no way Meyer can micro-manage his way to three national championships and an 85.1 winning percentage, but can’t communicate with his wife, who received messages from Courtney Smith claiming she had been abused.

This isn’t just about Meyer either. This situation and resulting suspension have been mishandled by Ohio State and the NCAA.

Los Angeles Rams running back Todd Gurley was suspended by the NCAA in 2014 while at the University of Georgia for four games for selling autographs, yet Meyer was only suspended three games for mishandling domestic abuse.

Are we really at a point where 18-24 year-olds are held to a higher standard than grown adults? Where’s the accountability?

Meyer is making nearly $8 million a year. There is no excuse for not knowing about any potential trouble your subordinates are getting into, especially if they have a history of DUIs and inappropriate behavior.

They all could have done better. They all should have done better.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Comment

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Where’s the accountability?

    Sports

    Women’s tennis gears up for great season

  • Where’s the accountability?

    Sports

    High hopes for men’s basketball season

  • Where’s the accountability?

    Sports

    Lady Eagles stay humble after National Championship win

  • Where’s the accountability?

    Sports

    Reynolds named men’s golf coach

  • Where’s the accountability?

    Sports

    More than just a president

  • Where’s the accountability?

    Sports

    Back to the basics

  • Where’s the accountability?

    Sports

    Finding a new groove

  • Where’s the accountability?

    Sports

    Screaming Eagles baseball: the team that plays together, wins together

  • Where’s the accountability?

    Sports

    Relieved to see Tiger Woods return

  • Where’s the accountability?

    Sports

    USI Men’s Track & Field finishes eighth at WashU invitational

University of Southern Indiana's student publication
Where’s the accountability?